Exploring the Love and Loss in 'The Fault in Our Stars': A Comparison of Book and Film

By Arushi Bharadwaj, B.A. Programme

Design by Nandana

Introduction

Both John Green's novel and Josh Boone's film adaptation of "The Fault in Our Stars" explore love and loss through the stories of two teenagers with cancer. This comparison highlights the differing representations of these themes in each medium.

Love in the Book

In the book, love is shown as a blend of joy and pain. Hazel and Augustus's deep discussions about life and mortality allow readers to see Hazel's reluctance to fully embrace love because of her fears of losing it. This complexity enriches their relationship.

Love in the Film

The film focuses on visual storytelling and key romantic moments, such as their trip to Amsterdam. While it effectively captures their chemistry, it often simplifies the philosophical conversations that are central to their bond in the book, resulting in a more romanticized depiction of their love.

Loss in the Book

Loss is a recurring theme in the novel, deeply felt through Hazel's perspective. Her internal struggles and fears about losing Augustus and leaving her parents emphasize the emotional burden of their relationship. The gradual acceptance of loss is sensitively portrayed, prompting reflection on grief.

Loss in the Film

The film conveys loss through dramatic moments, such as Augustus's decline, which evokes strong emotions. However, it tends to focus on these climactic scenes rather than Hazel's gradual acceptance of loss, which can reduce the complexity of her emotional journey.

Conclusion

While both the book and film address love and loss, the novel provides a deeper, more introspective exploration of these themes, whereas the film prioritizes striking visuals and emotional scenes. Together, they offer complementary experiences that resonate with audiences in different ways